Boycott: Sandpapergate worse than Cronje; Smith and Warner should have received five-year bans

Former England captain Geoffrey Boycott wrote in The Telegraph on 22 November 2026 that Australia’s 2018 ball-tampering scandal in Cape Town was more serious than Hansie Cronje’s match‑fixing and that Steve Smith and David Warner ought to have been banned for five years.
Boycott said he has never been convinced the punishments handed to Australia’s senior players were sufficient, noting that Smith and Warner served 12-month suspensions and Cameron Bancroft received nine months. He also recorded that no member of the coaching staff was punished following the Cape Town incident and that head coach Darren Lehmann was cleared by Cricket Australia’s investigation before resigning days after the scandal broke.
Writing in his column, Boycott said the scale of the Australian episode set it apart. "The sandpaper scandal is even bigger than Hansie Cronje's match-fixing, which ripped apart South Africa cricket more than 25 years ago. This is bigger than anything I have read or seen in cricket: a whole team cheating," he wrote.
He contrasted that alleged collective involvement with Cronje’s case and said Cronje primarily recruited two younger players. "Cronje's crimes mainly involved him recruiting a couple of junior players, Herschelle Gibbs and Henry Williams, into his scheme. The rest of the squad and coaches had no idea," Boycott wrote.
The article recounts the chronology of Cronje’s affair: his links with bookmakers came to light in April 2000, he initially denied the allegations, admitted four days later to accepting money from a London bookmaker, and was removed as captain that same week.
Boycott’s column cites details heard at the King Commission, saying Cronje tried to involve Gibbs and Williams in a fixing arrangement during an ODI against India in Nagpur and allegedly offered each player $15,000. According to the account, Gibbs was asked to score fewer than 20 runs and Williams to concede more than 50; neither complied — Gibbs scored 74 off 53 balls and Williams suffered a shoulder injury before completing his second over. Cronje was handed a life ban in October 2000, while Gibbs and Williams received six-month suspensions.
On the Cape Town affair, Boycott rejected the notion it was spontaneous and described planning and a subsequent cover-up. "What they did was so serious. It wasn't a spur-of-the-moment incident; it was carefully planned in two Tests in the hope of cheating to win and trying to get away with it by letting the junior player in the team do the dirty work because nobody would be watching him," he wrote, and added: "But sandpaper involved the whole Australian team. The squad and coaches were all up to their necks in it, plotting and planning to cheat en masse, and the cover-up let three players take the blame. It is mind-blowing and unbelievable how they all went along with it. That is how huge it is," he said.
Fresh revelations about the Cape Town Test have returned the controversy to the spotlight, and Cricket Australia along with senior players Pat Cummins, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Starc are facing renewed scrutiny.
