Four major creative missteps in WWE Survivor Series Premium Live Event history

17 Nov 2026, 07:38 pm IST|
Four major creative missteps in WWE Survivor Series Premium Live Event history
Image source

WWE Survivor Series is the focus of this review, which lists the top four creative blunders in the Premium Live Event’s history as the company stages its 40th edition this year. The compilation highlights incidents that provoked controversy, fan backlash or long-term fallout.

Survivor Series has produced landmark moments as well as contentious ones, and this year’s card features two WarGames matches, a traditional five-on-five Survivor Series match and other major matches including World title clashes. Despite that stacked lineup, the event’s history includes storylines and decisions that many observers call mistakes, some provoking debate for decades.

The Montreal Screwjob is presented as the most controversial entry: Bret Hart refused to drop the WWE Championship to Shawn Michaels in his home country, prompting Vince McMahon—unwilling to risk Hart leaving for WCW with the title—to order a finish that saw the referee ring the bell while Michaels had Hart in the Sharpshooter despite Hart never submitting. The aftermath featured Hart spitting in McMahon’s face and then punching him backstage, and the incident led to the creation of the “Mr. McMahon” character.

Survivor Series 2015 is cited for its handling of the WWE World Heavyweight Championship: Roman Reigns defeated Dean Ambrose to win the title but was immediately cashed on by Sheamus, who used Money in the Bank and left as champion. The decision drew instant rejection from fans, stalled Reigns’ momentum at the time and is described as one of the most criticized cash-ins of the decade, even though Reigns eventually recovered.

A 2002 Survivor Series outcome involving Brock Lesnar is criticised for cutting short Lesnar’s push: by 2002 Lesnar was undefeated and backed by Paul Heyman, yet he lost in a match lasting under four minutes when Big Show defeated him after Heyman betrayed Lesnar and aligned with the 7-footer. Critics argue the finish ended Lesnar’s undefeated streak too early and sacrificed the momentum of a rapidly rising star while delivering a win that did not change Big Show’s long-term direction.

The 2021 Survivor Series angle tied to Netflix’s Red Notice involved a prop Golden Egg valued at $100 million and a backstage disappearance that unfolded as a comedy-style whodunit. That storyline drew heavy criticism as forced product placement that, according to detractors, overshadowed in-ring action at a Big Four event, occupied valuable airtime and became widely mocked by fans and insiders.

Most fans and insiders point to the Montreal Screwjob when listing the event’s worst creative choices because of its real-life fallout, while the other incidents are noted for their immediate damage to storylines or tone. For more updates and coverage, follow Khel Now Wrestling on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram, download the Khel Now Android App or IOS App, or join their community on Telegram and Whatsapp.

The Montreal ScrewjobBret HartRoman ReignsSurvivor Series 2015Sheamus