Healy: Cummins will struggle to captain unless he rebuts Bancroft’s claim about 2018 Cape Town plan

19 Nov 2026, 12:35 pm IST|
Healy: Cummins will struggle to captain unless he rebuts Bancroft’s claim about 2018 Cape Town plan
Image source

Former Australia wicketkeeper Ian Healy said Pat Cummins will struggle to captain the Test side unless he explicitly refutes Cameron Bancroft’s assertion that the whole team knew about the 2018 ball‑tampering plan in Cape Town, remarks reported on November 19, 2026. Bancroft made the claim on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, and Cummins has previously dismissed Usman Khawaja’s account in Khawaja’s book as “complete and utter nonsense.”

Bancroft, described in coverage as one of the central figures in the 2018 'sandpapergate' scandal, said he took "the bullet" for everyone when he claimed the entire team knew about the conspiracy. Cummins responded to Khawaja’s written assertions during a press conference, using the phrase “complete and utter nonsense” to reject the suggestion that all players were aware of the ball‑tampering plot.

Speaking to SEN, Healy said: "I would feel without refuting Cameron Bancroft's words again, he (Cummins) will struggle to captain the team." Healy added: “You've had a big part of your credibility taken away with that press conference now that it's been proven to be not as complete as Pat made it out to be.”

Asked whether Cummins should stand down, Healy replied, "No, he doesn't need to stand down." He expanded on the original 2018 handling of the affair: "And I don't want to get into another panic mode of what happened in 2018, it was panic, and they tried to do an investigation in no time, didn't talk to anyone, it was rubbish. It was a lack of quality and rubbish, and rushed, and panicked." Healy is 62 and played in 119 Tests and 168 ODIs between 1988 and 1999.

Healy said the latest development would affect the personal reputations of Cummins and other senior quicks who had denied knowing about the plan, naming Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc and Nathan Lyon. “I would say it taints their personal legacies. I don't think it's going to taint their performance legacies. Personally now, they're not as credible as they once were, unless they change something drastically in the next few days," he said.

On the duration and impact of ball tampering, Healy stated: “Either side of this period where there was ball tampering happening — how long was it going before South Africa and and probably not much since - but they got very brazen with it, so that tells me it's probably been going on longer than we think. So they probably achieved some success with their skills, with a ball that's doing more than it was going to. That's a little bit of a part of their career legacy.”

Healy urged former coach Darren Lehmann to speak if he intended to, saying, "If he's going to do it, now's the time. But I think the dots have been joined there too. It was an ugly underbelly with an average attitude, and he was in charge of it.” Healy also accused Cricket Australia of a flawed initial inquiry and a possible cover‑up: “Yes, I think so...the panic and the chaos back here in Australia - they had no idea about it in South Africa - it was unbelievably emotional and led to a poor quality investigation which might have been covering up a motivation not to get everyone sacked." Healy opposed a full reinvestigation: “No. I don't think there's any value in it. The dots are joining for us now. So I’m saying no. It would be costly, it would be ugly, and continuing something that should have been better handled first time, but it could be wrapped up quite well without spending a whole lot of money, I reckon.”

Healy said he could not predict whether Cummins would relinquish the captaincy, adding: "Now, I can't say whether he should stand down now. Will he stand down? That might be a different thing. He might stand down," leaving the captain’s immediate position uncertain amid the renewed controversy triggered by Bancroft’s November 17 statement.

Pat CumminsCameron BancroftIan HealySandpapergateUsman Khawaja