Leny Yoro sent off eight minutes into Pochettino’s first United game at Anfield — was the red correct?

22 Nov 2026, 11:25 pm IST|
Leny Yoro sent off eight minutes into Pochettino’s first United game at Anfield — was the red correct?
Image source

Leny Yoro was shown a red card after eight minutes of Manchester United’s match against Liverpool at Anfield on 22 November 2026, a dismissal that occurred in Mauricio Pochettino’s first game as United boss and handed Liverpool the initiative, with Andoni Iraola’s side scoring twice in quick succession.

The sending-off was Manchester United’s earliest red card in the Premier League and immediately prompted debate over whether the challenge merited a straight red or should have been downgraded to a yellow following a VAR check. Refereeing guidelines set out four key considerations for denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity: distance from the offence to the goal, likelihood of keeping or gaining control of the ball, location on the pitch, and the number of defenders and attackers. Those criteria form the framework officials must apply when deciding if a foul prevents a clear scoring chance.

The sequence began with Ronald Araujo playing a long ball forward for Alexander Isak, who took a touch before Yoro "bundled into the back of the Sweden international and brought him down." Referee Sam Barrott awarded the foul and sent Yoro off without hesitation. Photographers at Anfield captured the full sequence from the initial challenge to the red card decision.

Three of the four denying-an-obvious-goalscoring-opportunity factors were met: Isak was running directly towards goal in a central position and there was no covering defender. The remaining question concerned the "likelihood of keeping or gaining control of the ball": Isak’s heavy touch moved the ball a few yards ahead of him, and that touch occurred before contact from Yoro, so the challenge did not cause Isak to over-run the ball. The referee and the VAR, John Brooks, therefore had to judge whether Isak would have reached the ball ahead of goalkeeper Senne Lammens and, if so, whether it would have been a good scoring opportunity; the guidance states that if there is any doubt it should not be a red card.

Officials described the incident as borderline, meaning the VAR would not be expected to intervene for a "clear and obvious error," and likewise would not intervene if the referee had shown a yellow. Former Liverpool and England midfielder Danny Murphy, speaking on Match of the Day, said there was "no doubt" about the red card. Former Manchester United defender Gary Neville agreed on Sky Sports: "Leny Yoro has to cover and he doesn't," Neville said. "He reacts late and his anticipation is poor. "It's so clumsy from Yoro. It's naivety, he just needs to get off the pitch. You're not going to get that turned around, no chance."

The season has already produced comparable incidents. Brighton’s Pascal Struijk was sent off at Sunderland after a VAR review for bringing down Wilson Isidor; Brighton successfully appealed that red on the grounds there was clear doubt that Isidor would have taken control of the ball before it ran through to goalkeeper Bart Verbruggen. Despite the Football Association regulatory commission unanimously ruling the Struijk red card was wrong, the Premier League’s key match incidents panel later voted the VAR intervention a correct call on a split 3-2 vote. In another example, Ipswich’s Issa Diop avoided a VAR red for a foul on James McAtee against Nottingham Forest when the referee disagreed with the video official and believed there was a covering defender; Forest boss Oliver Glasner insisted it had been a clear goalscoring opportunity, and the same referee, Thomas Bramall, officiated both of those incidents.

Manchester United can choose to appeal Yoro’s red card and, as the coverage noted, "there's nothing to lose by doing so." Given the recent mixed outcomes in similar cases and the split votes on VAR interventions, an appeal would determine whether the dismissal is upheld or overturned.

Leny YoroManchester UnitedLiverpoolMauricio PochettinoAlexander Isak