Newcastle 2-2 Arsenal at St James' Park — Madueke 'a consistent threat' in draw

Arsenal and Newcastle played out a 2-2 draw at St James' Park on Saturday in the Newcastle v Arsenal match, with Noni Madueke and Harvey Barnes scoring in the second half. BBC Sport's Alex Howell has published player ratings from the game.
Eberechi Eze opened the scoring for Arsenal in the first half before Harvey Barnes levelled after the break; Newcastle then went ahead when Malick Thiaw bundled in from a corner and Noni Madueke brought Arsenal level with an excellent strike, the match finishing 2-2. BBC Sport's Alex Howell rated the players — "What do BBC Sport's player ratings mean?" — and users were invited to submit their own assessments.
For Newcastle, goalkeeper Lukas Hornicek was given a 5 after kicking was described as "slightly erratic", nearly getting caught by Kai Havertz after taking too long to release the ball and being judged to have done better with the second Arsenal goal. Amar Dedic was booked for pulling back Eberechi Eze and received a 5, while Malick Thiaw earned an 8 after scoring the goal to put Newcastle in front and capping an excellent central defensive display. Dan Burn was rated 7 for some crucial first-half clearances and his role as Newcastle took the lead.
Lewis Hall was rated 7 after a big error for the opening goal but redeemed himself with a crucial block to deny Noni Madueke and several deliveries into the Arsenal box. Sean Steur, rated 6, was noted for quality on the ball and an unusual calmness for an 18-year-old but was taken off at half-time; Lewis Miley received a 7 for his ball quality and for operating as the deepest Newcastle midfielder in the second half. Jacob Murphy (5) had an early shot and was substituted at the break after a quiet first half, while Joe Willock (7) was credited with an all-action display whose physicality helped Newcastle improve after the interval.
Harvey Barnes was awarded an 8 for an "excellent finish" to bring Newcastle level and for being "always direct", and William Osula, rated 7, was judged isolated leading the attack but did well to assist the opening goal. Tino Livramento, introduced on 46 for Dedic, was given a 7 for making a "huge impact" after coming on at half-time; Anthony Elanga (on 46 for Murphy) was rated 6 for his pace, Jacob Ramsey (on 46 for Steur) 7 for adding drive, and Sven Botman replaced Hall on 92. Subs not used for Newcastle were Pope, Schar, Gonzalez, Wissa and Fernandez-Pardo.
Arsenal goalkeeper David Raya was rated 5 and was taken off with what looked like a serious shoulder problem after conceding twice. In defence Jurrien Timber received a 6 for using his aerial ability to progress play and for getting into dangerous positions, Ezri Konsa was given a 6 after appearing to be cruising before Arsenal conceded twice, Gabriel Magalhaes was rated 6 after becoming involved in a battle with Osula, and Riccardo Calafiori received a 6 for a quieter attacking display than usual.
In midfield and attack, Declan Rice was rated 7 for a strong start that could not prevent Newcastle's turnaround, Bruno Guimaraes received a 5 amid a hostile reception and was noted as having a clear first-half chance before being substituted, and Martin Odegaard was rated 6 after an uncharacteristic mistake that contributed to Newcastle's way back into the match but later setting up Madueke. Eberechi Eze scored the opening goal with a powerful finish and was rated 7, Noni Madueke scored a great goal to bring Arsenal level, was described as "A consistent threat." and was awarded an 8, while Kai Havertz was given a 7 for smart play and providing the pass for Eze's goal. Arsenal substitutes were Kepa Arrizabalaga (on 70 for Raya) rated 6 for a couple of smart stops, Myles Lewis-Skelly (on 70 for Guimaraes) rated 7 for a solid performance, and Christos Tzolis (on 70 for Eze) rated 6 for his work after coming on; unused Arsenal subs were White, Mosquera, Saliba and Hincapie.
After the opportunity to rate players had closed, BBC Sport stated that the score displayed represents the average from all the submissions by BBC Sport users. BBC Sport also promoted its Match of the Day Predictor game and its sport quizzes and club-following pages.

