Rugby brain-injury lawsuits threatened after claimants fail to disclose medical records

19 Nov 2026, 01:28 am IST|
Rugby brain-injury lawsuits threatened after claimants fail to disclose medical records
Image source

In court on Thursday, lawyers for hundreds of brain-damaged rugby players and for World Rugby, the Rugby Football Union and the Welsh Rugby Union were told the two long-running lawsuits are again on the brink of collapse after the claimants failed to disclose required medical documents. The claimants’ legal team has applied for an extension until January to complete disclosure.

The litigation has run for six years and the latest hearings were billed as a turning point toward a trial due to begin next October, when the parties were to submit shortlists of potential test cases. Lead counsel for the players, Paul Downes KC, conceded in June that the claimants were in the “last-chance saloon” after repeatedly missing court-ordered deadlines. Defendants’ lawyers say they still lack the medical records they need despite a series of court orders and told the court that “there is no watering hole” in sight.

Rather than progressing to the selection of test cases, the hearings became focused on whether the actions should stand as struck out because of breaches of the disclosure orders. The claimants had previously been granted relief from that sanction but are now seeking further relief in the form of the January extension.

KP Law took over the claim in June from Rylands Garth, which is no longer involved, and Downes told the court the case was in a “shambolic” state when his firm assumed conduct. He described Rylands Garth’s work as an “incredible failure” and said KP Law has provided an additional 2,000 documents relating to the medical testing, adding that “more has been achieved in the last 99 days than in the previous three years”.

Large gaps in disclosure remain: only 36 of the 385 players in the union case have letters of diagnosis. “It seems remarkable that anyone has been onboarded without a letter of diagnosis,” said Justice Cotter. Downes explained that Rylands Garth had no single universal database to identify which documents existed and which had not been produced, and that the firm had refused to share the files it did have until “some sort of exit agreement” was reached. “I assume fees were mentioned.”

Downes told the court he believed the proceedings could be recovered and submitted: “If it can be saved, it is my submission that it should be saved.”

The next step now rests with Senior Master Cook and Mr Justice Cotter, who will decide whether to grant the claimants the extension to January that would enable further disclosure and allow the selection process for test cases to proceed.

Brain InjuryPaul Downes KCKP LawRylands GarthMedical Disclosure