Rugby players await ruling after judges retire in concussion litigation hearing

20 Nov 2026, 01:27 am IST|
Rugby players await ruling after judges retire in concussion litigation hearing
Image source

Hundreds of former rugby players are awaiting a ruling after judges at the Royal Courts of Justice retired to consider whether their concussion claims can proceed following a two-day hearing.

The claimants allege neurological damage caused by the professional negligence of World Rugby, the Rugby Football Union (RFU), the Welsh Rugby Union (WRU) and the Rugby Football League; the two-day hearing had been intended to select a shortlist of test cases that would stand trial on behalf of the wider group.

Instead, the hearing focused on whether the claimants should receive relief from sanctions after their current legal team, KP Law, missed a court deadline for completing disclosure of documents related to the testing process undertaken by players when they joined the action.

When KP Law entered the case in July, its lead counsel Paul Downes KC described the prior disclosure work by Rylands Garth as "shambolic", and by that stage all 378 claimants in the rugby union case and the vast majority of the 173 in the rugby league case had been struck out because of the failure to disclose the relevant material.

Senior Master Cook previously granted the claimants relief from sanction on the condition that KP Law rectify the disclosure position by 30 October; KP Law says it has provided 2,000 additional documents but has appealed for a further extension until January to supply the remainder.

Nina Goolamali KC, lead counsel for World Rugby, told the court: "The litigation has been at the mercy of the complainants’ conduct for far too long," and argued the proposed trial date of October 2028 was not achievable or realistic given the disclosure delays; Neil Block KC for the RFU said it would be "impossible" to hold a trial at that date, while Michael Kent KC for the WRU said the case had become bogged down in "an endless debate about disclosure" and all three urged that the struck-out positions should stand.

Downes pointed to a list of 39 players — 22 in rugby union and 17 in rugby league — whom he said were "substantially in compliance" with the court orders, adding: "At its height I would say we have 39 compliant claimants, but the defence might dispute that and they might be right." He warned that if the remainder of the cases remained struck out the next stage would be "a very substantial piece of satellite litigation" about which the hundreds of claimants were in breach at the time of 30 October.

The presiding judges, Senior Master Cook and Mr Justice Cotter, are expected to deliver their decision in the coming days.

ConcussionKP LawPaul Downes KCDisclosureTest Cases