Selection of Manush Shah over Harmeet Desai for Mixed Team World Cup draws scrutiny
On November 19, 2026 in Chennai, the Table Tennis Federation of India announced Manush Shah in place of Harmeet Desai for the ITTF Mixed Team World Cup in Chengdu, scheduled from November 29 to December 6, a decision that has drawn sharp scrutiny of the selection committee.
The federation’s selection points system, released in July 2026, placed Harmeet 15 points clear of Manush and, by those published criteria, Harmeet should have been selected. Under the points breakdown cited by the TTFI, Harmeet has accumulated 55 points (domestic ranking: fourth, 35 points; world ranking: 102 as on Nov. 2, 20 points), while Manush has 40 points (domestic ranking: 10th, five points; world ranking: 45, 35 points).
Harmeet expressed his displeasure directly to the media. “I am disappointed. I deserve to be in the team. ”Harmeet
He expanded on that feeling in a later comment: “I am disappointed. I deserve to be in the team. If TTFI is considering doubles, I did well at the Asian Championships in Tashkent recently, winning bronze with Yashaswini Ghorpade. There is no clarity from TTFI. ‘What should I do to make it to the Indian team?’ I skipped a few WTT Feeder events to play in domestic tournaments and accumulate points. I did not enter WTT tournaments abroad because I believed I would be there in the team for the Mixed Team World Cup. In the previous editions of the tournament, the TTFI used its points system. So, why the change now?” Harmeet asked.
Observers noted the TTFI has applied its points policy in earlier selections. When naming the squad for the Asian Games in Aichi-Nagoya, the federation dropped Manika Batra because she had fewer points and designated her as a reserve. The selection has also been questioned because, by world rankings, Manush is ahead of Harmeet in men’s singles, men’s doubles and mixed doubles, and it is reliably learnt that the Indian team was chosen using the TTFI’s points system in all three previous editions of the Mixed Team World Cup. “This is unprecedented. The TTFI’s Selection Committee has bypassed its own policy and picked Manush. The federation has not made such an exception for Sharath Kamal or Manika Batra or any other top player in the recent past. Never before has any exception been made for any tournament,” a top paddler told The Hindu.
Indu Puri, chairperson of the ad-hoc committee, referred queries on the selection to the Selection Committee. One member of that committee, speaking on condition of anonymity, said: “It was a decision unanimously agreed upon by the committee. This is not a tournament like the Asian Games or WTT. The Mixed Team World Cup is different, with doubles playing a major role. The TTFI’s points system will not be applicable here. Manush is among the world’s top-six in mixed doubles and is the highest world-ranked Indian in men’s singles.”
Team for ITTF Mixed Team World Cup: Men: Ankur Bhattacharjee, Payas Jain, Manush Shah, Manav Thakkar. Women: Diya Chitale, Syndrela Das, Yashaswini Ghorpade, Sutirtha Mukherjee.
The announced squad is set to take part in the ITTF Mixed Team World Cup in Chengdu from November 29 to December 6.