Should India A pick Prabhsimran Singh ahead of Ayush Badoni at No. 3 in Rising Stars Asia Cup 2026?

India A face a selection question at the ACC Men’s Asia Cup Rising Stars 2026 after Ayush Badoni failed to make runs, including a four-ball duck on November 22 against Pakistan A, prompting calls to consider Prabhsimran Singh for the No. 3 spot in the remaining matches.
India A began the tournament with a 306-run victory over Nepal, but several top-order batsmen have produced modest returns: Abhishek Sharma made nine, Vaibhav Sooryavanshi scored 26 and Ayush Badoni managed two in the opener. Badoni’s subsequent dismissal for a four-ball duck while chasing 314 on November 22 has intensified debate over the composition of the top three.
Prabhsimran Singh’s List A record underpins the argument for his inclusion: he has scored 2,321 runs in 61 List A matches at an average of 44.63 and a strike rate of 105.98, with six centuries, 12 half-centuries and a highest score of 167. He also produced 510 runs for Punjab Kings in IPL 2026 at a strike rate of 168.87, and his attacking approach has been suggested as a way to accelerate the innings through the middle overs.
The Punjab batter’s regular role as an opener in domestic cricket and the IPL is cited as evidence of his familiarity with the new ball and constructing an innings from the start. With Vaibhav and Abhishek available to open, the proposal is to slot Prabhsimran at No. 3 to provide a more experienced top-order presence.
Ayush Badoni’s List A figures stand at 734 runs in 31 matches at an average of 31.91 and a strike rate of 91.29, including one century and five half-centuries. His bowling contributed against Pakistan A, where he took one wicket for 18 runs in five overs, dismissing Shamyl Hussain and breaking a 66-run opening stand, but his scores of two and zero in India A’s first two games have weakened his case as a top-order batter.
India A possess several bowling options beyond Badoni, with Harshit Rana, Prince Yadav, Shahbaz Ahmed, Vipraj Nigam and Suryansh Shedge all available to the team. That depth is cited in arguments that Badoni’s bowling, while useful, may not be indispensable if his batting continues to falter.
The immediate implication for India A’s selection is straightforward: the team could try Prabhsimran Singh at No. 3 in the remaining Rising Stars Asia Cup matches while retaining Ayush Badoni as a candidate for the middle order and a part-time bowling option.