Shubman Gill protests to umpires after Glenn Phillips survives controversial DRS call in Wellington

Indian captain Shubman Gill confronted match officials after a disputed DRS call left New Zealand’s Glenn Phillips not out on Day 1 of the first Test between New Zealand and India at the Basin Reserve in Wellington on Thursday, November 19. The incident occurred in the 31st over when Jasprit Bumrah struck Phillips on the back pad and India’s on-field appeal for LBW was turned down by umpire Richard Illingworth.
Gill had won the toss and elected to bowl, and India reduced New Zealand to 60 for 4 before lunch on Day 1. Jasprit Bumrah took three wickets, dismissing Tom Latham, Daryl Mitchell and Tom Blundell; Anshul Kamboj removed Devon Conway and Akash Deep dismissed Rachin Ravindra. Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips then began a recovery stand for New Zealand.
The DRS incident unfolded when Bumrah’s delivery hit Phillips on the pad in the 31st over and Illingworth ruled not out. Gill spoke briefly with Bumrah before choosing to review the decision; Bumrah expressed doubts about the ball’s height while Gill believed it had not struck the bat, prompting India to challenge the on-field call.
Third umpire Paul Reiffel reviewed the replay evidence after the referral was sent upstairs. The front-on angle appeared to show a gap between bat and ball, but Snickometer showed a spike as the ball passed the bat. After examining multiple camera angles, Reiffel concluded the ball had taken a slight inside edge before striking the pad and therefore upheld Illingworth’s not-out decision.
India consequently lost one of their review opportunities and Phillips remained unbeaten at the crease. Gill reacted visibly to the outcome, walking over to Richard Illingworth for a prolonged discussion and using hand gestures while explaining his disagreement. The on-field decision stood and play continued with Phillips batting.
The moment was broadcast during the match coverage, with a televised caption stating: "The skipper isn't pleased! 😤 A tense moment in the middle as Shubman Gill makes his case to the umpire! 👀 Watch the HERO VIDA India Tour of New Zealand, 1st Test, LIVE NOW on Sony Sports Network TV channels & Sony LIV.#SonySportsNetwork #SonyLIV #NZvIND pic.twitter.com/Jlh2oa40fc"
Phillips remained not out as play progressed on Day 1, with the upheld decision leaving India one review down and New Zealand continuing their innings at the Basin Reserve.