Tom Brady shows unexpected competence as Fox NFL color commentator

Tom Brady has emerged as an effective color commentator on Fox's NFL broadcasts this season, an improvement that was on display during Fox's coverage on Sunday of the 49ers' win over the Cowboys. The former quarterback, who began his Fox role in 2024, has shifted from early missteps to a clearer, more human broadcasting presence.
After initially being widely derided for his transition to television, Brady’s early stint in the Fox booth featured notable pauses and awkward asides that critics seized upon. The author of this piece began watching Fox’s NFL coverage after opting not to buy NFL Sunday Ticket when the Steelers hired Mike McCarthy as head coach, and observed Brady’s gradual development firsthand. Early examples included long pauses before straightforward observations such as “they are bringing all six, and they can only block five of them.” At times he used the platform for personal reflection, telling viewers: “The people that mattered the most to me were the guys in the locker room,” a remark made in the context of comments about Daniel Jones.
Brady’s explanatory work in the 49ers-Cowboys game illustrated the change; he broke down Christian McCaffrey’s 66-yard catch-and-run in the fourth quarter using the telestrator to show how Dallas’s pressure package left McCaffrey matched up against Von Miller. “He’s one-on-one with Von Miller because they’re pressuring on the inside,” Brady said. “That’s not the assignment Von Miller’s looking for.”
He provided a rapid, detailed analysis of Deebo Samuel’s 70-yard reverse touchdown, using the all-22 angle and the telestrator to highlight San Francisco’s misdirection. “They basically eliminated 10 of the 11 defenders,” Brady said, and he invoked a “red wave” when describing how the play unfolded. During the sequence he also reacted audibly when Brock Purdy threw a block to help Samuel score.
Brady’s response to a ticky-tack personal foul on 49ers safety Malik Mustapha demonstrated a more sympathetic, schematic approach to officiating and player intent. “When you play this coverage, that is what the safety position is supposed to do on any throws there. That’s the risk-reward of throwing there,” Brady said after Kevin Burkhardt noted it looked vicious in real time. “It all sounds that way,” Brady said, and then explained the safety’s responsibilities in cover-two.
Residual rough edges remain in Brady’s work: he briefly got hung up on a word that sounded like it was supposed to be “presence” during a longer explanation and aborted a sentence before moving on. Alongside those slips, his audible excitement at big plays and the benefit of extensive media training contribute to a personality that comes across as genuinely engaged with explaining football.
Midway through his third year on the job, Brady is described here as one of the more stable color commentators in football, a position the author contrasts with the situations facing Troy Aikman, Joe Buck and ESPN, Tony Romo at CBS, and replacement JJ Watt with Jim Nantz. The piece notes that some media critics regard Sunday Night Football’s Cris Collinsworth as the only commentator in a more authoritative spot than Brady, and adds that this evolution has altered perceptions of his broadcasting role.