Was Morgan Rogers' handball decision correct in Chelsea's 4-1 home defeat by Leeds?

Morgan Rogers was penalised for handball when referee Michael Oliver awarded a penalty during Chelsea's 4-1 home defeat by Leeds on Saturday in the Premier League, a call that VAR did not intervene on and has prompted debate among pundits and managers.
Handball penalties are relatively uncommon in the Premier League: last season there were 22 penalties for handball across 380 games, easily the lowest total compared with Spain's La Liga (36) and Italy's Serie A (38). This season the Premier League has recorded three handball penalties in 106 matches, fewer than in 2025-26, and Premier League clubs generally accept an interpretation in which a punishable arm offence requires the arm to be fully extended away from the body, raised, or to be a deliberate act.
Match officials cited two core factors when judging the incident involving Rogers. Jayden Bogle's shot came from distance, giving a defender more time to adjust, and Rogers' arm moved — it was not raised when the shot was struck but came up to the flight of the ball. The assessment noted that had Rogers kept his arm lower and level with his midriff there would not have been a handball offence, but that the arm being raised and the ball being deflected off it constituted a deliberate act.
There was a question over whether the contact occurred too high on Rogers' arm, which the laws refer to as the 'red zone', and that would have been the only circumstance in which VAR Michael Salisbury might have considered an on-field review. A comparable situation from last season involved Anton Stach's strike and Everton defender James Tarkowski, who leaned into the path of the ball with his arm tucked close to his side; Everton manager David Moyes described that decision as "wrong", but the article states it "was absolutely correct in law."
Pundit Alan Shearer expressed scepticism about the ruling, saying: "I didn't agree with the penalty when Michael Oliver gave it. I know once the on-field decision is made there is a high bar to review it, but I don't think officials are allowed to use common sense. Morgan Rogers is not deliberately trying to stop the ball. He just doesn't want it hitting him in the face. Although the penalty came at an important point in the match, Chelsea were deservedly beaten by a much stronger, far more physical and better-organised Leeds team." Rogers may argue he raised his arm to protect his face, which the article notes can be a mitigating factor only when a player raises their hands to their face rather than using the arm as a barrier.
Chelsea manager Xabi Alonso, speaking to Sky Sports, said: "For me it was quite a harsh decision. I would not have given a penalty. I don't want to make a big thing about it but for me it's not a penalty."

