How large a competitive step has a player taken between consecutive club matches?
Malachi Fagan-Walcott ended last season playing for York City against Rochdale in the National League and began the 2026-27 campaign with Hearts against Sturm Graz in a Champions League qualifier; a reader asked whether any player has made a bigger jump in competitive level between successive club games. Several readers supplied candidates and historical examples, including a notable case from an FA Cup semi-final in 1987.
Russell Connor nominated Gary Plumley, who made almost 200 appearances for Newport County across four spells over a decade but by 1987 had effectively retired and was running a wine bar while making occasional appearances for Ebbw Vale in the Welsh League. In the run-up to the 1987 FA Cup semi-final, Watford were left short of goalkeepers after Tony Coton and Steve Sherwood suffered a broken thumb and a broken finger respectively, and Plumley — whose father Eddie was Watford’s chief executive at the time — was signed to play. Watford lost the semi-final 4-1, Plumley’s performance was widely criticised and he received only a cheque for expenses, which the family used to buy what they called the Watford Fridge; the Guardian archive and an interview with Plumley cover the episode.
Kári Tulinius noted that “Erling and Alf-Inge Haaland bought the only surviving copy of the first printed edition of Snorri Sturluson’s medieval history of Norwegian kings and donated it to their hometown of Time in Norway.” Tom Reed added a separate example: in 2017 Mousa Dembélé purchased a 700-year-old building in Antwerp for conversion into a hotel and during renovations a trove of 18th-century porcelain, glass, pottery and tableware was found; Dembélé donated part of that find, reportedly valued at over £1m, to the local museum and put the remainder on display in the hotel lobby, which he named De Gulde Schoen (The Golden Shoe).
Ian Golightly flagged an instance from Scottish football: Sean Murdoch was the referee for St Mirren v Dunfermline in the Scottish League Cup and had previously been a goalkeeper who played for Dunfermline. A 2010 round-up of former players-turned-referees highlighted Steve Baines as the only referee in the English professional leagues with significant playing experience, Dick Jol — who officiated the 2001 Champions League final between Bayern Munich and Valencia — and Ben Haverkort, who as a player accumulated 73 yellow cards and six reds, many for verbally abusing referees.
The women’s game provided a recent example of a player becoming a top referee: Cheryl Foster MBE won 63 caps for Wales and spent most of her club career at Liverpool before retraining as a referee; within three years of playing her final game she was on the Fifa international list and later took charge of the 2023 Women’s Champions League final between Barcelona and Wolfsburg. On retirement Foster said: "There's a picture of me picking the ball out of the little Jeep that drove the ball on to the pitch and I had the biggest smile," and added, "To describe those feelings of doing major tournaments and a big final is incredible."
On older goalscorers, Mykola Kozlenko pointed out a missed entry: 58-year-old Mykola Lykhovydov of Real Pharma in Ukraine, covered in a Guardian article last year, who will not beat the new record as his club was relegated from professional football this summer after finishing last for two seasons in a row. Tom Weir recalled that Ally MacLeod scored a penalty for Queen of the South reserves in 1992 at the age of 61.
Paul Gage asked whether Rochdale’s preliminary-round League Cup penalty shoot-out win over Tranmere, 2-1, was the fewest goals in such a shoot-out; respondents recalled the 1986 European Cup final between Barcelona and Steaua Bucharest, which finished 0-0 after extra time and went to penalties where Helmuth Duckadam saved four spot-kicks from José Alexanko, Ángel Pedraza, Pichi Alonso and Marcos Alonso as Steaua won 2-0. Duckadam was later forced to retire due to a rare vascular disease in his right arm. Other noted low-scoring shoot-outs include Thailand’s 1-0 win on penalties over Bangladesh in the 1973 Merdeka Tournament and Singapore’s 1-0 win over Cambodia in the same competition, while a world-record low-scoring youth shoot-out occurred in January 1998 when under-10s Mickleover Lightning Blue Sox beat Chellaston Boys 2-1 on penalties after 66 spot-kicks; further penalty-run facts are available at rsssf.com.
Readers also posed a range of miscellaneous questions: whether Mikel Arteta’s single English title leaves him the only manager with title-winning experience entering the new season; Kerim Alajbegovic’s transfer pathway from Salzburg to Leverkusen on 1 July for €8m and an impending move to Juventus for €37m, giving Leverkusen an estimated profit of around €1m per day Alajbegovic was at the club; Tigres UANL’s Diego “Chicha” Sanchez being cited as the shortest professional player at 5ft 1ins and having scored against San Luis; which footballer has played for the most clubs; the driving distance between Gateshead International Stadium and St James’ Park suggested by Google Maps as 3.5 miles (2.3 miles if walking); and Wrexham defender Max Cleworth containing the letters of “Wrexham” within his name.
Mail us with your questions and answers.
